Posts

Ford-autonomous-Fusion-test-car

Self-Driving Fords Could Be on Phoenix Roads by Summer

Jennifer van der Kleut

Some may not realize, in addition to racking up miles at Michigan’s Mcity testing ground, Ford Motor Co. has also been logging plenty of miles at another testing ground - the Arizona Proving Ground.

Now, after what they say has been countless hours of successful testing around the Proving Ground, located in Wittman outside Phoenix, media are reporting that self-driving Fords could be ready to hit public roads by this summer.

KPNX 12 News in Phoenix obtained video of a self-driving Ford Fusion navigating real-world road situations at the Proving Ground this week, and posted it on its website.

The video shows “a hands- free safety driver driving seamlessly through various road features thanks to multiple onboard sensors and cameras,” KPNX said.

Ford researcher Jim McBride said Ford is pleased with how all tests have been going, and is confident their cars will be attractive to the public - and, above all, safe.

“Every time I’ve had someone ride in the car,  within five minutes, they’ve completely forgotten that a computer is driving them around,” McBride said to KPNX. “And their next question is, ‘When can I buy one?'”

The Phoenix Business Journal points out that Ford has made a point to test its self-driving cars in extreme conditions, such as ice and snow in Michigan, and now in the sun, heat and dirt of Arizona.

McBride told the Business Journal will head to California next. Ford previously opened a research and development center in Silicon Valley.

“It’s nice to test the car in sunshine, but every place presents unique challenges,” he said. “Eventually we want to drive everywhere, but first we have to go out and map everything. The algorithm development is first.”

McBride also told the Journal that its autonomous car project is close to entering the “advanced development” phase, at which point the company will triple the number of autonomous test cars in its fleet.

McBride said Ford is confident that its car is on track to be available to the public within four to five years-but that safety is important above all else.

“We’re more concerned with safety and the mass market than getting it out first,” he said.

NissanFuture3

Nissan Video: Fossil Fuel is for Fossils

Burney Simpson

Nissan believes our auto future is an all electric, autonomous, and sustainable-powered vehicle - no fossil fuel here -  that generates enough energy to power its owner’s home, according to this new video from the auto OEM.

The vehicles will garner their power from solar/wind/what-have-you sustainable sources.

They will communicate with each other to schedule alternating visits to the Vehicle-to-Infrastructure wireless recharging stations that have been implanted in the streets.

The car will be emission free, so it can drive INTO your office, then take itself to the closest recharging station. That’s apparently right down the hall from the kitchen so you can watch Nessy get a charge up while you get your coffee.

The video makes it look effortless. I expected to see butterflies floating through the model city here that has replaced its parking lots with parks. (By the by, what happens to all the lovely gas stations we enjoy today?)

It’s fascinating that a major auto OEM — revenues of $104 billion in fiscal 2014 —  is working to end the use of fossil fuels to power vehicles. (At least that’s what they say).

And it let’s potential buyers know of one of the major side-benefits of electric vehicles. That is, buy a Nissan Leaf  and get both an economical car and a power source for when the lights go out.

The video by Nissan Europe and Foster + Partners was released at the Geneva Motor Show.

However, the video doesn’t address some of the other radical changes that driverless technology may bring to firms like Nissan.

For instance, by 2030 Mary Consumer will opt for a car-share service instead of buying a car. That means GM’s $500 million investment in Lyft will prove to be farsighted when it evolves into Transport MegaCorp X, and supplies Metropolis Y with 500,00 vehicles that its 10 million residents share.

So it’s possible that Nissan will stop selling cars to consumers. Perhaps by 2030 it will have morphed into an energy company that markets its batteries. Naah, I don’t see that either. But it could become Transport MegaCorp N.

Anyway, check out the ‘Fuel Station of the Future’ video. It’s well made and offers much to think about.

 

MichArmyTest1

Video — Army to Invade Michigan with Connected Trucks

Michigan’s Interstate 69 will host this summer a vehicle-to-infrastructure (V2I) road test with the U.S. Army.

A convoy of army trucks outfitted with sensors, radar, LiDAR, and other equipment will travel the route and test their V2I and Vehicle-to-Vehicle (V2V) communications technology. The trucks will communicate with roadside transponders, sharing such information as their speed and location. The transponders will be transmitting to the trucks information on weather, speed limits, and local lane closures.

According to Automotive News, the transponders cost $5,000 apiece, and have a range of 300 yards. Paul Rogers of the Army’s tank research center in Warren, tells the pub the test equipment is about $175,000 per vehicle, though a real-world application would bring that cost down.

Check out this older video of a similar test. Couple things –

  1. This is not, repeat NOT, the Blue and Maize Glee Club prepping for The Game.
  2. The Potemkin village in this looks a lot cooler than Mcity. I’m not saying I’m just saying.

VaTennMap2

Careful Steps on Driverless Laws for Tennessee, Virginia

Burney Simpson

State legislatures in Tennessee and Virginia are working methodically in their review of driverless technology laws.

For now, the focus is on ensuring that the language of any new law fits current definitions and statutes covering vehicle technology and driver requirements.

“There’s excitement and cautiousness. (People) get concerned when you talk about a fully autonomous vehicle,” said Del. Glenn Davis, a Republican in the Virginia General Assembly.

Right now states are hesitant to pass any rules on driverless technology, said Anne Teigen, a program principal, and policy specialist transportation, with the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL).

“The challenge for the states is that they want to react but they don’t want to stifle innovation. They are trying to find a balance,” said Teigen.

Teigen in January updated the NCSL’s page devoted to autonomous legislation, noting there were then 32 proposals in state legislatures related to the vehicles. The website doesn’t cover connected vehicle activity.

In Tennessee, state Sen. Mark Green introduced SB 1561 that would allow road testing of the driverless vehicles. Green argues this will encourage auto manufacturers to start building the cars in the state.

GM, Nissan, and Volkswagen, and Tier 1 supplier Denso already operate manufacturing plants in Tennessee.

Green declined to share names but says he has had discussions with auto OEMs and suppliers on driverless testing in the Volunteer State.

The bill is far from a sure thing. Green must rewrite some of the language so a driverless vehicle operator meets the state’s definition of a vehicle driver. He plans to officially propose it to the Senate Transportation Committee in a few weeks.

This summer, the state’s DOT, its motor vehicle department, and others may designate a road corridor for testing vehicle-to-infrastructure (V2I) and vehicle-to-vehicle (V2V) communications, says Green.

OLD DOMINION STAYS NEW

In Virginia, the House and Senate have approved a proposal from Del. Davis that legalizes monitors showing live images in a vehicle when the vehicle is being operated autonomously.

The bill’s language is convoluted but it was necessary to override an existing law that fought distracted driving, said Davis.  

“We needed to address this. This is a first step. We need to make sure the laws are safe both for standard mode (vehicles) and autonomous vehicles,” said Davis.

The proposal now goes to Virginia Gov. Terry McAuliffe for his signature. McAuliffe last year launched Virginia Automated Corridors, a state initiative on the research and development of automated vehicles.  

Davis also proposed a bill that would define autonomous vehicles but it got bottled up in committee and will probably expire when the state’s legislative session ends in March.

He might reintroduce the proposal next year, expanding it to include a definition of automated-vehicle technology, like lane assist and cruise control, along with that of autonomous vehicles.

That combination of familiar technology with cutting-edge driverless could sway more legislators to vote for the bill, says Davis.

“New vehicles are bringing this combination of automated technology and driver control,” said Davis. “Once people are comfortable with (lane assist), you will see more acceptance of (autonomous).”

While the states move slowly, the U.S. Department of Transportation is setting the pace on federal policy.

Its National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) division will release this summer a policy foundation for autonomous vehicles. This will include a definition of the vehicles, testing policies, and guidance on their deployment and operation.

NHTSA will also release a model driverless car policy for the states.

The feds just may overtake the states on this one.

Graphic by brisray.com.

cavcoecar2

Controlling the Disruption of Autonomous Technology

Burney Simpson

Autonomous cars could be the disruptive technology that disrupts just about everything.

A new conference in Canada, “Automated Vehicles: Planning the Next Disruptive Technology” is designed to update transportation experts on the technology and help them prepare for its impact.

The event from the Conference Board of Canada will run April 19-20 in the One King West Hotel in Toronto.

The conference will address autonomous technology and its impact on urban planning, security and privacy, transit, and the movement of commercial goods. See the agenda here.

The conference arises in part from a 2015 paper from the consultant Canadian Automated Vehicles Centre of Excellence (CAVCOE), and the Conference Board. (See “Autonomous Vehicles to Save Canada $54 Billion, Many Lives”).

One year later, the Conference Board is organizing the event and the timing is right, says Barrie Kirk, executive director of CAVCOE, a conference sponsor.

For instance, a test of autonomous vehicles on public roads began near Toronto in January, and the government just released its 10-year strategic transportation plan that includes some mention of autonomous technology. The Toronto test could bring driverless cars traveling on everything from Highway 401 to suburban side streets, according to the Ontario Ministry of Transportation.

“We’re seeing the winds of change blow through our federal government,” said Kirk. The newly-elected Liberal government “is more open. They seek partnerships. And policy groups are seeing disruptive technology coming.”

CAVCOE is taking advantage of the open mood to request that 1 percent of the 18 billion (Canadian) the nation spends on infrastructure be devoted to smart infrastructure, says Kirk. That 180 million Canadian converts to $133 million U.S.

Smart infrastructure covers a lot of ground, notes Kirk, including autonomous vehicles, emissions, data and privacy, cybersecurity, weather, and distracted drivers.

The conference is also sponsored by the Canadian Automobile Association and BlancRide, a Canadian carpooling service.

Photo by CAVCOE.

FordFusionAuton1

Ford to Triple Mobility, Autonomous Tech Funding

Burney Simpson

Ford will triple its investment in driver-assist and autonomous-vehicle technology, Ford CEO Mark Fields pledged at the massive Mobile World Congress 2016 in Barcelona yesterday.

The technology includes hands-free parking assist, and traffic jam assist, which Ford will roll-out within three years.

Fields stressed in a keynote address that Ford is “an auto and mobility company” and not just an auto company, according to the Associated Press.

“(P)eople want mobility solutions, they want options, whether it’s car-sharing, ride-sharing, what we call multi-modal modes of transportation where you are taking a car for a portion of a journey or a train and then maybe a bike,” said Fields.

He called the mobility programs “a big revenue opportunity.”

Ford’s European car-sharing programs include GoDrive in London, and Ford Carsharing in Germany. The German project has 170 stations in small and medium-sized cities, and its bookings rose more than 75 percent last year, according to Ford.

At Mobile World Ford was promoting its in-vehicle Sync connectivity system that is compatible with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. It is to be launched in Europe this year. The driver can use voice commands to Sync to control navigation, audio, and vehicle climate, Ford said.

Ford’s aggressive announcement at the Mobile show follow the $500 million investment that rival GM made in the ridesharing firm Lyft in January (See “GM Invests Half a Billion in Lyft for Autonomous Car Network”). Lyft is estimated to be worth between $4 billion and $5 billion.

The Mobile World Congress last year drew 94,000 attendees from 200 countries. It runs through Thursday, February 25.

Traffic Jam Assist is a push-button system for use in crowded, slow-moving traffic. It keeps the vehicle in its lane, and accelerates and brakes in accord with the vehicle ahead.

Ford announced last month at the CES 2016 it would expand the number of its Fusion Hybrid autonomous research vehicles. That meant Ford was testing 30 of the vehicles in Arizona, California, and Michigan.

JaguarUJack1

UK Combines Driverless Pod, Vehicle Tests in Milton Keynes

Burney Simpson

Only 41 miles of road separate Coventry and Milton Keynes in the UK. But those miles may provide a route to 21st Century transportation.

The two midsize cities are contributing to one segment of the three-part test of connected and autonomous vehicles going on this year in the United Kingdom. Bristol and London are running the other two segments (See “London Tests Fully Autonomous, Electric-Powered Pod Transit”).

The trials in Milton Keynes and Coventry offer a mix of geographic areas and vehicle types.

There will be seven standard road vehicles along with 40 pods, otherwise known as low-speed autonomous transport systems. The pods will operate on sidewalks and other areas where they share space with pedestrians.

The road vehicles include three from Jaguar Land Rover, and two each from Ford and Tata Motors European Technology Center.

Plans call for the standard vehicles to eventually test Vehicle-to-Vehicle (V2V) and Vehicle-to-Infrastructure (V2I) communications technology.

The Milton Keynes/Coventry test is covered in the article “MK dons a collaborative approach” that runs in the latest issue of Smart Highways, a three-year-old pub covering intelligent transport systems in the UK. The author is Mark Ledsom, communications manager for Transport Systems Catapult.

The Milton Keynes/Coventry program is overseen by the UK Autodrive consortium. The three-year project has funding of 18.2 million pounds, or $25.8 million, and includes 16 member organizations.

The pods are built by Coventry-based RDM Group, and include autonomous systems from Oxbotica, the spin off from the Mobile Robotics Group at Oxford University.

As the tests are going on, UK Autodrive will organize and oversee three working groups, according to Ledsom.

The safety, data security and V2X communications group will develop recommendations for future deployments.

The urban issues group will look at the coming impact of driverless technology on cities in both a 10-year and a 25-year time frame. Mobility and congestion issues will be top of mind.

The third group will conduct surveys on autonomous and connected issues, in Coventry, Milton Keynes, the UK, and such world cities as Los Angeles and Shanghai.

Milton Keynes is home to Bletchley Park, where the Brits broke the Nazi’s Enigma codes in WWII. Scientists there created the ‘bombe’ electromechanical device that deciphered the German’s strategic plans, thus saving countless lives and shortening the war.

Transport Systems Catapult was established by the government agency Innovate UK to drive intelligent mobility for transporting goods and people.

Photo by Jaguar Land Rover.

Sightstream-16b

Valeo’s Intuitive Driving = Autonomous Driving + Connected Car + HMI: a Q&A with Amine Taleb

Editor’s note: This is another in DT’s series of Q&As with leaders in the automated, connected, and driverless vehicle industry.

ATalebMug1Dr. Amine Taleb is the manager of advanced projects for Valeo’s Comfort and Driving Assistance (CDA) Business Group in North America, where he leads the advanced engineering in Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS) applications. He has more than 20 years’ experience in advanced technologies with technical expertise in the opto-electronic field. Dr. Taleb graduated from the University of Michigan with a doctorate in Physical Chemistry.  

 Valeo is an automotive supplier dedicated to the reduction of CO2 emissions and to the development of intuitive driving. In 2014, the company generated sales of $16.7 billion. It has 133 production sites, 50 research and development centers and 15 distribution platforms in 29 countries.

Sustainability is a major goal for Valeo. How do you incorporate sustainability in your development of autonomous technology?

Research and development plays a fundamental role in such a goal, by innovating in areas that lead to greener and more efficient mobility. This is why Valeo is focusing its efforts on developing solutions for the reduction of CO2 emissions and pioneering “Intuitive Driving,” which includes autonomous driving as one of its three pillars. The two other pillars are connected car and advanced human-machine interface (HMI). To accomplish this, recruiting the best talent and building a solid expertise foundation are key. In addition, listening to the consumer and partnering with technology leaders, who share common principles, are key towards these goals.

SightstreamCarAValeo in December purchased the German firm peiker, known for its expertise in mobile communications technology. How will this help Valeo as countries build V2V and V2I communications?

The acquisition of peiker is another step on our journey towards the connected car. Peiker is a market leader in automotive telematics connectivity solutions, and coupled with our on-board electronic know-how, it will help us develop innovative vehicle connectivity and telematics solutions. One of the examples in connectivity is V2X, which is gaining more and more traction worldwide, with the U.S. leading the V2V efforts for safety applications. We see V2X as a key element towards the connected and automated car, and also towards smarter mobility. This is very much in line with our vision of Intuitive Driving.

In November you partnered with Capgemini to offer mobility for corporate fleets and car rental firms. Where is this available? How does it work?

Valeo InBlue technology is a vehicle smart-key access system using smartphone technology. One feature is secure virtual key sharing suited for various car-sharing models. Capgemini has an expertise in digital solutions and IT integration that will enable the development of customizable mobility solutions with applications for corporate fleets and car rental.

The InBlue mobility solution will be tested out on a smaller scale with Parcours, a French leasing services company. InBlue is packed with an extensive suite of tools such as vehicle access and start, geo-localization, remote vehicle data access, etc., which will benefit end-users and fleet administrators.

You showcased a number of forward-thinking products at CES 2016. Your Sightstream camera system is designed to replace rear view mirrors. How does Sightstream work? Can this be sold in the U.S. where vehicles must have rear view mirrors? What clients are using the technology?

Sightstream7smallThe Valeo Sightstream camera system relies on the combination of high resolution camera and display to fulfill, to a minimum, the visibility requirements of conventional exterior mirrors. The exterior mounted camera projects the captured rear view scene onto the display located in the interior of the car. Innovations that improve vehicle aerodynamics are one of the keys to achieving the U.S. regulatory fuel efficiency target of 54.5 mpg by 2025. Sightstream enables automakers to improve aerodynamic drag by five percent which improves overall vehicle fuel economy.

Compared to conventional exterior mirrors, Sightstream also provides an enhanced visibility based on its wider field of view, which can potentially lead to the elimination of the blind spot. Other advantages are improved visibility in daytime, nighttime, and even in adverse weather driving. This technology may also increase driver situational awareness when other advanced safety sensors are added.

Rearview mirrors are federally regulated safety devices so any updates to the standards are necessary to allow such technology on the road. The Sightstream camera system utilizes mature technologies already in production. Because of the benefits I have highlighted, and with the maturity of these key components, it is just a matter of time before we would see camera monitoring systems in production cars, potentially as early as 2017 in Europe.

Cruise4U manages steering, accelerating and braking, and it allows drivers to switch between manual and autonomous control. What clients are using this, and when will it be available?

Valeo Cruise4U is a demonstration vehicle that highlights the simple integration of two unique ADAS sensors, namely front camera and Scala laser scanner, which are key building blocks for the sensor fusion architecture of Level 2 and higher automated driving. Both of these sensors are production intent technologies with the Scala to be launched by a major OEM in early 2017. While I am not at liberty to discuss details of any ongoing collaboration we might have with any carmaker, we are a key partner to major OEMs in the development of automated parking and automated driving solutions.

Scala was developed with Ibeo, Mobileye, and IAV. What is Valeo’s approach to partnering with other tech providers?

The Valeo Scala laser scanner provides unique features such as its wide field of view, detection range, high precision in object detection and tracking while driving up to highway speeds. Also, objects in its field of view, moving or not, are classified, thus enabling a precise path planning and maneuver.

The Scala was developed for automotive high-volume OEM applications through our exclusive partnership with Ibeo, a leader in high-tech laser scanner technology for automotive applications. In addition, the front camera, such as the one used on Cruise4U, will take advantage of Mobileye’s EyeQ chip vision technology.

By partnering with IAV, an engineering firm and vehicle integrator, we were able to integrate these advanced sensors in our Cruise4U.

In a very fast moving market, strategic partnerships with world leading companies are essential to effectively build up cutting edge capabilities necessary for autonomous driving technologies.

Your Mobius 2 product also allows for switching from manual to autonomous driving. With Mobius 2 the driver can interact with their tablet or smartphone while in autonomous mode. Is the world ready for this much distraction?

WebviewA-smallOne of the benefits of automated driving is not only to provide safe driving, but also to eliminate the driving boredom of being stuck in a slow-moving traffic or mundane long distance highway driving. Mobius enhances the user experience, while keeping safety in mind. By mirroring the smart device to the instrument cluster during autopilot mode, the driver is able to interact with it using the reconfigurable steering wheel switches. That ensures the driver’s eyes are in the direction of the road and his hands are in proximity of the steering wheel. That allows for a very quick takeover, if requested by the vehicle. That is important, particularly for Level 3 automation.

The Valeo Mobius was tested on a simulator at the Fraunhofer Institute in Germany. Test drivers’ takeover time was measured while interacting with the smart device via the Mobius, versus holding the smart device in their hands while the car was in autopilot. The results have clearly shown that takeover via the Mobius was 500 milliseconds faster than when holding the device in their hands. This could mean life or death at highway speed.

Mobius 2 has a camera monitoring the driver for signs of distraction and fatigue. Has there been pushback from clients/consumers on technology that watches the driver?

WebViewC-smallThe Mobius cockpit concept was subjected to tests by more than 60 end-users during worldwide clinics last year. We have not heard or felt pushback by any of them for having the camera monitoring their distraction or signs of fatigue. On the contrary, and especially in the takeover transition phase from automated to manual, end-users expected to be monitored and validated as capable to take back control of the car. The benefit seen by the driver exceeded the perceived annoyance of being monitored. In our findings, driver monitoring was found to be necessary for the increased trust in automated driving.

Moreover, if we focus on safety benefits of a driver-monitoring camera, in addition to other types of monitoring sensors such as steering wheel sensing in the Mobius, I believe these have an enormous advantage in protecting the driver from being distracted by smartphone and tablet usage while driving in manual mode. Every car should be equipped with such technologies to ensure the “eyes on the road” and “hands on the wheel,” and deter the crashes and fatalities caused by such distractions.

How do you break down doors at auto OEMs that aren’t using your driverless technology?

With our global footprint, and innovation in our DNA, our goal is to be partners with all the major OEMs, as well as emerging ones, in accomplishing autonomous driving. While each OEM might have different strategy towards automated driving, our innovation roadmap allows us to adapt our functions and products for each customer. The Scala is a good example of our strategy as it is the first automotive-grade laser scanner, soon to be on the market for automated driving.

To summarize, the car of tomorrow should be safer, cleaner, and more intelligent, and driving should be more fun and enjoyable. That’s our Intuitive Driving approach.

Thanks Amine.

The Intelligent Parking Chair is inspired by Nissan's Intelligent Park Assist technology. (PRNewsFoto/Nissan Motor Co Ltd.)

Nissan Brings Us Self-Driving……Chairs?

Jennifer van der Kleut

Japan may not have self-driving cars loose on public roads yet-but they at least have self-driving chairs.

Yes, we said chairs! In a new video uploaded to YouTube, Nissan shows off its latest creation-office chairs that reset themselves to their original position, tucked into a table or desk, at just the clap of your hands.

Nissan’s fancy, autonomous “smart chairs” can reset themselves either with or without a human sitting in them.

In a press release, Nissan explains the new technology behind the chairs, which they say was inspired by self-parking technology they are already working on in cars.

The system appears to function with sensors on each chair that pair up with wireless cameras placed on the room’s ceiling.

“The ‘Intelligent Parking Chair’ is a unique chair that automatically moves to a set position,” Nissan’s press release states. “The chair includes a roller to automatically move 360 degrees, paired with a system that indicates the target position. Four cameras placed on the room’s ceiling generate a bird’s-eye view to wirelessly transmit the chair’s position and its route to destination.”

When the chairs are empty, someone can clap their hands and all the chairs in the room will automatically guide themselves back into position at the table, as Nissan’s video illustrates.

When someone is in the chair, he or she appears to be able to use controls, similar to those on an electric wheelchair, to guide themself back into position at the table.

Though they call the self-parking chairs a “novelty,” Tech Times said, “It’s proof that autonomous vehicle technology has implications far beyond the automotive field.”

Tech Times points out that the smart chair technology could prove particularly valuable for large rooms like auditoriums and cafeterias.

See Toyota’s self-parking smart chairs in action in their YouTube video:

 

Screen Shot 2016-02-10 at 9.29.11 AM

Google Wins Patent for Driverless Delivery Trucks

Jennifer van der Kleut

In an exciting development, news outlets are reporting this week that Google has won a patent for self-driving delivery trucks.

According to publications like Quartz and The Verge, the patent application includes illustrations of trucks that would have a series of lockers that could be opened with an exclusive pin number by the person waiting for the delivery. Alternate options include allowing the person to swipe the credit card they used to make the purchase. The application implies the customer could choose a delivery window and the method of retrieving the package from the truck.

The Verge reports that the patent application indicates that the technology that would navigate the self-driving trucks functions similarly to that of its fleet of self-driving test cars.

The application implies that the person waiting for the delivery would be texted when the truck was close, or if the truck was running behind its specified time window.

Quartz writes that this patent application “dovetails nicely” with Google Alphabet’s current patent for autonomous delivery drones-an idea for which Amazon hopes to beat them to market, though there’s no telling when that might happen. Amazon has already released a handful of commercials promoting its future “Amazon Prime Air” service.

“…Whenever the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration figures out how to incorporate commercial drones into the national airspace, [Amazon] will be ready to set up its service,” Quartz writes.

There’s no telling when we might see driverless delivery trucks from Google. The Verge speculates that Google merely wants to patent all aspects of the idea before any competitors can do so.

“Most of the patent is taken up with covering every possible base. Google doesn’t pay these fancy lawyers for nothing.”